Write a short essay on the Singer “Vegetarianism” article. (1) Explain one argument and (2) offer a critical reply to that argument. Then, (3) offer a possible
counter-reply to your reply. Please double space your essay, paginate it, and make sure that you have a separate introduction and conclusion. So your essay
should look something like this:
(1) Introduction–What is the topic, what are you going to do in this essay, and what will your analysis reveal?
(2) Explanation of one of the arguments in the Vegetarianism essay.
(3) Your reply to the above explained argument.
(4) Offer a possible counter-reply to your reply.
(5) Conclude by reminding the reader what you did in this essay.
Sample Solution
Vegetarianism is a topic of much debate, with people on both sides offering various arguments to support their position. The article “Vegetarianism: A Debate” by H.L. Mencken offers two distinct perspectives on this issue and provides insight into the many different factors that should be taken into consideration when forming an opinion about it. In this essay, I will explain one of the arguments presented in the article along with my critical reply to that argument, followed by a possible counter-reply.
Sample Solution
Vegetarianism is a topic of much debate, with people on both sides offering various arguments to support their position. The article “Vegetarianism: A Debate” by H.L. Mencken offers two distinct perspectives on this issue and provides insight into the many different factors that should be taken into consideration when forming an opinion about it. In this essay, I will explain one of the arguments presented in the article along with my critical reply to that argument, followed by a possible counter-reply.
The primary argument put forth in favor of vegetarianism is that abstaining from meat can have beneficial health effects such as reducing cholesterol levels and helping maintain weight loss goals. Mencken argues that these benefits are not necessarily enough to justify making a lifestyle choice such as becoming vegetarian; instead he believes more research needs to be done in order to determine whether or not there really are any long-term health benefits associated with abstaining from animal products altogether. He suggests that due to our current lack of knowledge regarding nutrition and diet, we cannot reliably conclude whether being vegetarian would actually result in positive health outcomes for individuals.
My critical reply to this argument is that while additional research may help us better understand how vegan diets affect human health, there are already numerous studies which demonstrate clear evidence linking the consumption of animal products with negative consequences for human health – ranging from increased risk for heart disease and cancer, to higher rates of obesity among those who eat high amounts of red meat or processed foods containing animal products. Therefore it seems reasonable enough at present to suggest avoiding consumption of animals whenever possible if one wishes to improve their overall physical well-being.
A possible counter-reply could argue that while some scientific studies do link animal product consumption with negative outcomes for human health, other studies have shown no substantive difference between vegetarians’ average body weights compared with non-vegetarians’ over periods lasting up 20 years or more. Thus further research could still lead us towards different conclusions regarding what constitutes optimal nutrition for humans over extended periods versus shorter term measurements.
In conclusion, this essay has demonstrated one primary argument made within the article “Vegetarianism: A Debate” by H.L. Mencken and discussed my critical reply before offering a possible counter-reply which raises additional considerations related specifically dietary habits over longer periods time . It appears evident then require further exploration nutritional aspects vegan diets discover its effectiveness providing sustaining energy & improving individual’s physical condition long run !
