Write a 4-5 page essay, addressing the following two aspects:
(1) On the basis of class material, discuss two major similarities between the legacies of British colonization of Ireland and European colonization of Rwanda (approximately 3 pages). Provide specific examples from the course material, and cite every sentence where you reference a source (reading, documentary or video lecture).

(2) Some claim that colonization had “positive aspects,” or that former king Leopold II of Belgium was not responsible for atrocities, “because he never went to Congo” (see https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-53017188). The latter BBC article starts with the following:
Inside the palatial walls of Belgium’s Africa Museum stand statues of Leopold II – each one a monument to the king whose rule killed as many as 10 million Africans. Standing close by, one visitor said, “I didn’t know anything about Leopold II…”
Many Europeans are not taught about the atrocities committed by colonizers. Do you believe that more knowledge about the effects of colonization would have positive outcomes for the relations between former colonizers and the countries who were formerly colonized? Justify your answer (approximately 1 page).

 

Sample Answer

Sample Answer

 

The Legacies of British Colonization of Ireland and European Colonization of Rwanda
British colonization of Ireland and European colonization of Rwanda share several major similarities in terms of their legacies. Both cases involved the imposition of colonial rule by a foreign power, resulting in significant social, political, and economic transformations in the respective regions. Furthermore, these colonizations had lasting impacts on the identities and relationships of the colonized populations.

Imposition of Political Control: In both Ireland and Rwanda, colonization led to the imposition of political control by the colonizers. The British colonizers in Ireland sought to establish dominance over the local population and suppress any resistance to their rule. This was achieved through policies such as the Penal Laws, which discriminated against Catholics and restricted their rights. Similarly, during European colonization of Rwanda, the Belgian colonizers implemented a system of indirect rule, using local elites to enforce their authority while marginalizing and exploiting the majority Hutu population.

In the case of Ireland, the Penal Laws severely restricted the political and economic opportunities for Catholics, leading to their marginalization and perpetuating sectarian divisions that persist to this day (Kenny, 2014).

In Rwanda, the Belgian policy of favoring the minority Tutsi population over the majority Hutu population exacerbated ethnic tensions that ultimately played a significant role in the Rwandan genocide in 1994 (Mamdani, 2001).

Economic Exploitation: Both British colonization of Ireland and European colonization of Rwanda involved economic exploitation of the colonized regions. The colonizers sought to extract resources and wealth from these areas for their own benefit, often at the expense of the local populations. This economic exploitation had long-lasting effects on the socio-economic development of both Ireland and Rwanda.

In Ireland, the British implemented policies that prioritized the export of agricultural products, such as grain and cattle, over meeting the needs of the local population. This led to widespread poverty and famine, most notably during the Great Famine in the mid-19th century (Ó Gráda, 1999).

Similarly, in Rwanda, the Belgian colonizers introduced cash-crop production, primarily coffee and tea, which displaced subsistence farming and disrupted local economies. This contributed to socio-economic inequalities between different ethnic groups and laid the groundwork for future conflicts (Mamdani, 2001).

The legacies of British colonization of Ireland and European colonization of Rwanda are characterized by political control, economic exploitation, and long-lasting social divisions. These similarities shed light on the broader patterns of colonialism and its impacts on colonized societies.

The Importance of Knowledge about the Effects of Colonization
Knowledge about the effects of colonization is crucial for fostering positive outcomes in relations between former colonizers and formerly colonized countries. Many Europeans are not adequately taught about the atrocities committed by colonizers, as highlighted in the BBC article mentioned earlier. This lack of awareness perpetuates ignorance and hinders meaningful reconciliation and understanding between these nations.

Acknowledgment and Accountability: By increasing knowledge about the effects of colonization, former colonizers can acknowledge their historical role in perpetuating injustices and human rights abuses. This acknowledgment is essential for moving forward with accountability and addressing past grievances. It allows for a more honest dialogue between former colonizers and formerly colonized countries.

For example, in recent years, there have been efforts in Belgium to confront its colonial past regarding Congo. The opening of the Africa Museum with a more critical approach to colonial history demonstrates a growing recognition of the need to confront past atrocities (BBC News, 2018).
Reconciliation and Healing: Knowledge about colonization’s effects can contribute to reconciliation and healing processes between former colonizers and formerly colonized countries. By understanding the historical context and legacies of colonization, both sides can empathize with each other’s experiences and work towards mutual understanding.

For instance, increased knowledge about colonization can help address systemic inequalities inherited from colonial times. It can inform policies aimed at redressing historical injustices and promoting social justice.
Promoting Cultural Exchange: A deeper understanding of colonization’s effects can foster cultural exchange between former colonizers and formerly colonized countries. It allows for a more nuanced appreciation of diverse cultures and histories, leading to enriched relationships based on mutual respect and collaboration.

By learning about the contributions and resilience of formerly colonized countries, Europeans can develop a more comprehensive understanding of their shared histories.

In conclusion, increasing knowledge about the effects of colonization is essential for promoting positive outcomes in relations between former colonizers and formerly colonized countries. Acknowledgment, accountability, reconciliation, healing, and cultural exchange are all benefits that can emerge when societies confront their colonial pasts with honesty and empathy. By fully understanding these legacies, we can work towards a more just and inclusive global community.

 

 

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer