CRITICALLY DISCUSS A PIECE OF RESEARCH RELEVANT TO PRACTICE USING A CRITIQUING FRAMEWORK AND DISCUSS ITS FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS IN THE CONTEXT OF CURRENT PRACTICE
Sample Solution
The research paper “The effectiveness of a web-based mental health intervention for police officers” (van Rooij et al., 2021) is an investigation into the efficacy of a web-based psychotherapeutic intervention for police officers who are experiencing psychological distress. The study was conducted over a period of three months and involved 93 participants from various force areas across Europe. The main outcome measure was changes in symptoms related to depression, anxiety and stress as measured by the Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 before and after the intervention.
The authors used multiple sources in order to assess the validity of the research, including qualitative interviews with five police officers prior to commencing. Rigor was also addressed through random allocation of participants to either control or experimental groups as well as using intention-to treat analyses when analysing data collected during follow up sessions. Results indicated that those who participated in the web based interventions reported lower levels of depression, anxiety and stress compared with those who did not partake – highlighting its potential usefulness when addressing mental health issues within this population.
This research has many implications for current practice – it suggests that online interventions may prove useful when working with individuals from hard-to reach populations such as police forces due their anonymity/flexibility ease access./ Furthermore, emphasis placed on self directed care could enable greater personal autonomy which could promote better recovery outcomes amongst those affected. Finally findings have shown promise in terms reducing stigma associated with seeking help among law enforcement personnel – hinting at potential wider societal benefit if similar courses were implemented more widely
Despite its strengths there are some limitations – such as lack diversity between forces or small sample size which can lead bias/under representativeness; further research replicating these findings larger cohorts different settings would be beneficial increase confidence results obtained here
Sample Solution
The research paper “The effectiveness of a web-based mental health intervention for police officers” (van Rooij et al., 2021) is an investigation into the efficacy of a web-based psychotherapeutic intervention for police officers who are experiencing psychological distress. The study was conducted over a period of three months and involved 93 participants from various force areas across Europe. The main outcome measure was changes in symptoms related to depression, anxiety and stress as measured by the Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 before and after the intervention.
The authors used multiple sources in order to assess the validity of the research, including qualitative interviews with five police officers prior to commencing. Rigor was also addressed through random allocation of participants to either control or experimental groups as well as using intention-to treat analyses when analysing data collected during follow up sessions. Results indicated that those who participated in the web based interventions reported lower levels of depression, anxiety and stress compared with those who did not partake – highlighting its potential usefulness when addressing mental health issues within this population.
This research has many implications for current practice – it suggests that online interventions may prove useful when working with individuals from hard-to reach populations such as police forces due their anonymity/flexibility ease access./ Furthermore, emphasis placed on self directed care could enable greater personal autonomy which could promote better recovery outcomes amongst those affected. Finally findings have shown promise in terms reducing stigma associated with seeking help among law enforcement personnel – hinting at potential wider societal benefit if similar courses were implemented more widely
Despite its strengths there are some limitations – such as lack diversity between forces or small sample size which can lead bias/under representativeness; further research replicating these findings larger cohorts different settings would be beneficial increase confidence results obtained here