- Address each opinion produced by your chosen case. Generally, however, you should emphasize the majority opinion of your chosen case. 2. The most effective case comments generally engage in critique. That is, the author evaluates an argument of his or her choosing and discusses the merits or demerits of the argument—is it a good argument, 3. For this assignment, keep your case comment simple. Your case comment will be complete if you do the following things: state the issue or issues that are the focus of the comment. " mention whatever facts are necessary to give context to the issue(s). " discuss how the court decided the issue(s). " discuss (briefly) any wider implications of the decision that you can determine. " provide a final, closing comment on whether you agree with the court's decision, and give the reasons why. 4. Your case comment doesn't need to follow the exact order of the components above. Depending on your argument, a different ordering may promote a better logical flow. However, if you do follow the order above, your case comment will be reasonably well-organized. 5. The eligible cases for this assignment are fairly long. You are not expected to be able to cover all aspects of the decision you choose. It is more important to properly identify feminist legal issues and discuss them intelligently than to cram the maximum amount of information possible into seven pages. That said, you are expected to exercise reasonable judgment and to select important, rather than trivial, issues. 6. Make sure that you really understand the issue(s). The best way to do that is to read the case many times. Read the entire case even if you only discuss one issue among many.
The case can be access. on https://scc-csc.lexum.com/scc-csciscc-csc/eMtem/2182findex.clo? q.Newfoundla.+%28Treasury.Boarcl%29+v.+NAPE%2C+%5B2004%5D+3+S.C.R.+.1
Sample Solution