Columbus Shouldn’t Be a Holiday

  Columbus Shouldn’t Be a Holiday Christopher Columbus is often celebrated as the man who discovered America and is honored with a national holiday in the United States. However, there is a growing movement arguing that Columbus shouldn’t be a holiday. This essay will present several reasons why Columbus Day should be abolished and replaced with a different holiday that better represents the values and history of the United States. Historical Inaccuracy One of the main arguments against celebrating Columbus Day is the historical inaccuracy behind it. While Columbus did arrive in the Americas in 1492, he was not the first person to discover the continent. Native Americans were already living there for thousands of years before Columbus’s arrival. Celebrating Columbus as the discoverer erases the rich history and contributions of indigenous peoples and perpetuates a Eurocentric narrative of American history. It is important to honor and respect the true history of America, which includes recognizing the native populations that were here long before Columbus. Legacy of Violence and Exploitation Another reason why Columbus shouldn’t be celebrated is the legacy of violence and exploitation associated with his voyages. Columbus’s arrival marked the beginning of European colonization of the Americas, which resulted in the displacement, enslavement, and genocide of millions of indigenous people. Celebrating Columbus as a hero ignores these atrocities and sends a message that violence and oppression are worthy of celebration. Instead, we should promote holidays and figures that represent unity, respect, and justice for all. Cultural Insensitivity Columbus Day also raises issues of cultural insensitivity. Native American communities have long protested against the celebration of Columbus Day, viewing it as a painful reminder of the loss and suffering their ancestors endured. By continuing to observe this holiday, we disregard their perspective and perpetuate a culture of ignorance and disrespect. It is crucial that we listen to and respect the voices of marginalized communities and create inclusive holidays that celebrate diversity and promote cultural understanding. Alternative Holidays Instead of celebrating Columbus, we should consider replacing Columbus Day with a holiday that better reflects the true values and history of the United States. One option is to commemorate Indigenous Peoples’ Day, which has gained popularity in recent years. This holiday would honor the contributions, resilience, and rich cultures of Native American communities. Another alternative is to celebrate Exploration Day, which recognizes all explorers who have contributed to human progress without focusing solely on one individual. This would allow for a more inclusive celebration that acknowledges the achievements of diverse cultures throughout history. Conclusion In conclusion, Columbus Day should not be a holiday in the United States. The historical inaccuracy, legacy of violence and exploitation, and cultural insensitivity associated with Christopher Columbus make it inappropriate to continue celebrating him as a national hero. Instead, we should embrace alternative holidays that promote inclusivity, respect, and an accurate representation of American history. It is essential that we create holidays that reflect our values as a diverse nation and acknowledge the contributions of all individuals who have shaped our country’s past and present.  

Sample Answer