Electronic monitoring has many potential ethical pitfalls

    Electronic monitoring has many potential ethical pitfalls. In this activity, you will examine ethical issues associated with electronic monitoring in the criminal justice system. Scenario Imagine that the local court system has just revamped their bail procedures, and the effect of these changes has resulted in a large increase in the number of defendants being released as opposed to being kept in custody until their court date. The probation department has been tasked with finding technology that will allow the department to monitor this much larger number of defendants without needing to increase staffing. There have been public reactions questioning the ethical nature of electronic monitoring devices used by the corrections system. It is your job to create talking points that address three ethical concerns of your choosing.
    • We will provide clear and comprehensive information to defendants about the data being collected, how it is being used, and their rights regarding this information.
    • We will have a regular auditing process, to ensure that the data collected is only that which is needed."

Ethical Concern 2: Potential for Bias and Discrimination

  • Talking Points:
    • "We are aware that the use of electronic monitoring could disproportionately affect certain populations, particularly those from marginalized communities.
    • We are committed to ensuring that our monitoring practices are fair and equitable. We will regularly analyze data to identify and address any potential biases in our system.
    • We will provide training to our staff on cultural competency and implicit bias to ensure that monitoring decisions are made fairly and without prejudice.
    • We will work with community stakeholders to address concerns about potential disparities and to develop strategies for mitigating them.
    • We will regularly review the data, to ensure that there is not a disproportionate amount of any one group being monitored."

Ethical Concern 3: Impact on Rehabilitation and Reintegration

  • Talking Points:
    • "We recognize that excessive or overly restrictive electronic monitoring could hinder a defendant's ability to rehabilitate and reintegrate into society.
    • We are committed to using electronic monitoring in a way that balances public safety with the defendant's need for rehabilitation.
    • We will work with defendants to develop individualized monitoring plans that are tailored to their specific needs and circumstances.
    • We will provide defendants with access to support services, such as job training and counseling, to help them succeed during their monitoring period.
    • We will have a process to review the monitoring period, and to remove the monitoring when it is no longer needed.
    • We will seek feedback from those who have been monitored, to improve the process."

Conclusion:

"We believe that electronic monitoring can be a valuable tool for ensuring public safety and defendant compliance. However, we are committed to using this technology in a responsible and ethical manner. We will continue to engage with the community and stakeholders to address concerns and to ensure that our monitoring practices are fair, transparent, and effective."

Talking Points: Addressing Ethical Concerns of Electronic Monitoring

Introduction:

"The recent changes to our bail procedures have necessitated the use of electronic monitoring to ensure public safety and defendant compliance. We understand that this technology raises ethical questions, and we are committed to addressing these concerns transparently and responsibly."

Ethical Concern 1: Privacy and Surveillance

  • Talking Points:
    • "Electronic monitoring, by its very nature, involves a degree of surveillance. We recognize that this can intrude on an individual's right to privacy.
    • We are committed to using this technology in a manner that is proportionate to the risk posed by the defendant. We will only collect data that is directly relevant to monitoring compliance with court-ordered conditions, such as location and curfew adherence.
    • We have implemented strict protocols to protect the confidentiality of the data collected. Access to this information is limited to authorized personnel and is used solely for the purpose of monitoring compliance and ensuring public safety.

Aced Essays

Free Resources