Individual Response Journal: Comparing Baldwin and Hurston

    Individual Response Journal: Comparing Baldwin and Hurston Comparison of Experiences: Baldwin's experience in 1903, as depicted in his autobiographical work, is both similar to and different from Curbo's experiences earlier in post-Civil War and early 20th century America. As Black Americans, both Baldwin and Curbo face the challenges of living in a hostile society that discriminates against them based on their race. However, their experiences as fathers and sons differ. Curbo, as a father, had to navigate the complexities of raising a son, Lewis, in a racially divided society, where opportunities were limited for Black individuals. On the other hand, Baldwin, as a son, had to grapple with his own identity and sense of belonging, while also witnessing the struggles faced by his father. Both Baldwin and Curbo have cause for anger due to the systemic racism and injustices they encounter. Baldwin expresses his anger at the hypocrisy and ignorance of white Americans, while Curbo, as a father, is angry at the limited opportunities available for his son due to racial discrimination. Despite the challenges they face, both Baldwin and Curbo have reasons to be grateful. For Baldwin, he acknowledges the strength and resilience of his ancestors who paved the way for him to survive in a hostile society. He is grateful for the love and support he receives from his family and community. Similarly, Curbo expresses gratitude for the small victories and moments of joy amidst the hardships faced by Black Americans. What keeps each of them going during hard times is their unwavering determination to fight for justice and equality. Baldwin finds solace in his writing and uses it as a tool to challenge societal norms and advocate for change. Curbo, as a father, finds strength in his love for his son and his desire to provide him with a better future. Both men maintain hope despite the adversity they face. Lessons on Being a Black Man in America: These narratives by Baldwin and Hurston provide valuable insights into the challenges of being a Black man in America. They shed light on the systemic racism, discrimination, and prejudice that Black individuals have historically faced and continue to face today. The narratives highlight the psychological toll of navigating a society that constantly questions one's worth and denies equal opportunities based on race. Furthermore, these narratives offer insights into American society as a whole. They expose the deep-rooted racism that has permeated various aspects of society, including education, employment, and social interactions. Both authors reveal the stark contrast between America's ideals of freedom and equality and the harsh realities experienced by Black Americans. Quotes from James Baldwin: "I am what time, circumstance, history, have made of me, certainly, but I am also so much more than that." (Baldwin) This quote showcases Baldwin's struggle with identity and how he refuses to let society define him solely based on his race. "To be a Negro in this country and to be relatively conscious is to be in a rage almost all the time." (Baldwin) This quote reflects Baldwin's anger at the racial injustices he witnesses and experiences. "I love America more than any other country in this world, and exactly for this reason, I insist on the right to criticize her perpetually." (Baldwin) This quote demonstrates Baldwin's complex relationship with America, where he criticizes its shortcomings while still holding onto a deep love for his country. Quotes from Zora Neale Hurston: "Ships at a distance have every man's wish on board." (Hurston) This quote symbolizes the hopes and dreams of Black Americans despite the obstacles they face. "But she had been married thirty years and had borne him twenty-two children… And she was still slim-bodied" (Hurston) This quote showcases the strength and resilience of Black women even in the face of adversity. "There is no agony like bearing an untold story inside you." (Hurston) This quote highlights the importance of sharing one's experiences and shedding light on the untold stories of Black Americans. In conclusion, both James Baldwin and Zora Neale Hurston provide profound insights into the challenges faced by Black men in America. Through their narratives, they expose the systemic racism ingrained in American society while also emphasizing the resilience and strength of Black individuals. Their stories urge us to confront the injustices that persist today and work towards creating a more equitable society.  

Sample Answer