An example of a business dispute involving intellectual property occurred in 2018 when U.S. District Judge Robert Sweet ruled in favor of Swiss watchmaker Swatch Group AG against Richemont North America Inc., who had been accused infringing design their famous Cartier Tank watch . The court held that while both parties watches shared similarity certain aesthetic elements their respective designs were distinct enough constitute separate pieces art thus granting relief sought Swatch Group ultimately favoring them outcome case. I do believe judge made correct decision this instance because despite similarities between two products there still very clear differences each which allowed court differentiate them establishing proper ownership , something imperative ensuring fair marketplace where creators receive credit due hard work efforts put into creating own unique products . Additionally ruling set important precedent upholding value creative expression letting perpetrators know will face consequences if found guilty infringing someone else\'s copyright protected material . Overall it evident all different types intellectual property play integral role production sale goods services society today providing necessary protections ensure artists received deserved recognition any profits earned through exploitation their creations misleading consumers alike therefore essential take into account length remedies available order ensure best interests all those involved handled properly at end day