Issues associated with qualitative research and evidence-based practice
1-What are some issues associated with qualitative research and evidence-based practice? Create a list of these issues with explanations concerning how they are addressed.
2- What criteria must be met in order to consider a practice, evidence-based? Give some examples [three to four examples].
-
- Addressing Integration: Mixed-methods research designs can effectively integrate qualitative and quantitative approaches. Researchers can use triangulation to validate findings from multiple sources.
- Criteria for Evidence-Based Practice
- Clinical Expertise: The practitioner's knowledge and skills are essential to interpret the evidence and apply it to individual patient needs.
- Best Available Research Evidence: The practice should be supported by high-quality research evidence, such as randomized controlled trials (RCTs), systematic reviews, or meta-analyses.
- Patient Values and Preferences: The patient's values, preferences, and circumstances should be considered when making clinical decisions.
- Hand Hygiene: Evidence-based hand hygiene practices, such as using alcohol-based hand sanitizers, have significantly reduced healthcare-associated infections.
- Early Mobilization for Post-Surgical Patients: Early mobilization has been shown to reduce complications, such as deep vein thrombosis and pneumonia, in post-surgical patients.
- Opioid Prescribing Guidelines: Evidence-based opioid prescribing guidelines have helped to address the opioid crisis by reducing unnecessary opioid prescriptions.
- Non-Pharmacological Pain Management Techniques: Techniques such as relaxation, meditation, and acupuncture have been shown to be effective in managing pain, especially in conjunction with pharmacological interventions.
Qualitative research, while invaluable for understanding complex phenomena, presents certain challenges when integrating it into evidence-based practice (EBP):
- Subjectivity: Qualitative research often involves subjective interpretations and analysis, which can raise concerns about reliability and validity.
- Addressing Subjectivity: Rigorous research design, including clear coding and analysis frameworks, can enhance objectivity. Inter-rater reliability checks can also help minimize bias.
- Generalizability: Qualitative studies often involve small sample sizes and specific contexts, making it difficult to generalize findings to larger populations.
- Addressing Generalizability: Researchers can use purposeful sampling to select diverse participants and conduct multiple case studies to increase the transferability of findings.
- Integration with Quantitative Research: Combining qualitative and quantitative research methods can provide a more comprehensive understanding of complex issues. However, integrating the two can be challenging due to their different methodologies.