Logical and Physical Design

 

In order to ensure optimal database performance, the logical and physical design should consider the user requirements thoroughly. Suppose you have been hired to transform a conceptual model into a logical model for a sales database.

Describe the specific steps that you must perform in order to appropriately construct the database model.
Speculate the risks that might present themselves for each step mentioned, and how you would avoid or mitigate those risks.

 

Risk: The main risk here is inappropriate data type selection. Using a data type that is too large (e.g., a VARCHAR(255) for a two-letter state code) wastes storage space. Conversely, using a data type that is too small (e.g., an INTEGER for a product ID that will eventually exceed the integer limit) can lead to data truncation or overflow errors. Another risk is a lack of data normalization, which can lead to redundant information.

Mitigation: To mitigate these risks, meticulously analyze the data requirements for each attribute. Work closely with the business team to understand the maximum length of text fields and the range of numerical values. For normalization, apply the rules of First, Second, and Third Normal Form to eliminate redundant data. For example, storing a customer's address in every sales record is redundant; it should be in a separate Customer table linked by a key.

 

Step 3: Defining Primary and Foreign Keys

 

After defining the tables and columns, you must establish the relationships between them. This is done by defining primary keys and foreign keys. A primary key is a unique identifier for each record in a table, and a foreign key is a column or set of columns in one table that refers to the primary key of another table.

Risk: A significant risk is the incorrect establishment of relationships, which can lead to orphaned records, referential integrity issues, and inaccurate data. For example, if a foreign key in the 'Sales' table doesn't correctly link to the 'Product' table, a sales record could refer to a non-existent product.

Mitigation: Careful relationship mapping is essential. For every relationship in the conceptual model (e.g., a 'Customer' can have many 'Orders'), you must define the correct primary and foreign keys. Use cascading rules (e.g., ON DELETE CASCADE) with caution, as they can sometimes lead to unintended data loss. Verify the relationships by drawing an entity-relationship diagram (ERD) to visually represent the links and ensure they make logical sense.

 

Step 4: Normalization

 

Normalization is the process of organizing data in the database to reduce data redundancy and improve data integrity. While it's a part of Step 2, it's so critical that it warrants its own discussion. The goal is to break down large tables into smaller, less redundant tables. The most common normalization levels are 1NF, 2NF, and 3NF.

Risk: The primary risk of normalization is over-normalization, which can lead to an excessive number of tables and complex joins for simple queries. This can negatively impact database performance. For example, separating a customer's first name and last name into different tables for the sake of "normalization" is an unnecessary step that adds complexity.

Mitigation: The key is to find the right balance. Aim for Third Normal Form (3NF) as a general rule. This is typically sufficient for most business applications. Document the reasons for any deviation from 3NF. This helps future developers understand the design choices and prevents them from over-normalizing the database. Regularly review the database design to ensure it meets both the data integrity and performance requirements of the application.

Sample Answer

 

 

 

 

 

 

Creating a logical database model from a conceptual model is a crucial step in ensuring optimal database performance. The process involves several key steps, each with its own set of risks and mitigation strategies.

 

Step 1: Transforming Entities into Tables

 

The first step is to transform each entity from the conceptual model into a table in the logical model. An entity represents a real-world object or concept, like 'Customer' or 'Product.' In the logical model, this becomes a table with a unique name.

Risk: The primary risk is a mismatch between the conceptual entities and the logical tables. This can lead to tables that are too broad, combining multiple concepts into one, or tables that are too narrow, with each entity having its own table when they should be combined. This can result in poor data organization and inefficient querying later on.

Mitigation: To avoid this, you should conduct a thorough review with stakeholders to ensure the logical tables accurately represent the business requirements. For example, if 'Customer' and 'Customer Address' are separate entities, a discussion is needed to determine if they should be a single table or two linked tables. Using a data dictionary to define each entity and its attributes is also an effective way to maintain clarity and prevent ambiguity.

 

Step 2: Defining Attributes and Data Types

 

Next, you need to define the attributes for each table. An attribute is a property of an entity, like 'Customer Name' or 'Product Price.' In the logical model, these become columns in the tables. You must also assign a data type to each column (e.g., VARCHAR for text, INTEGER for numbers, DATE for dates).