Watch the story of the movie Secret of the Wild Child, currently available in its entirety at the following web address:
Questions to answer:
Briefly describe Genie’s early experiences and her progress in learning a language after she was found.
What does this case study suggest about the role of language in the primary socialization process?
What is the critical period? Does research with Genie support the notion of what linguists refer to as a “critical period” for language acquisition?
Why is this case study referred to as a “forbidden experiment”?
Why can’t we reach definitive conclusions about cause and effect using a case study? Regarding Genie’s situation, what potentially confounding variable makes it difficult to conclude with certainty that it was extreme social isolation that caused her cognitive deficits?
Describe the ethical issues surrounding Genie’s case, discussed in the film Secret of the Wild Child. Did the individuals involved in this research project behave in an unethical manner?

Sample Answer

Sample Answer



The Tragic Tale of Genie: Unraveling the Mysteries of Language Acquisition

Language acquisition is a fundamental aspect of human development, shaping social interactions, cognitive abilities, and emotional expression. The case study of Genie, the “Wild Child,” offers a poignant insight into the critical role of language in the primary socialization process and the profound impact of extreme isolation on cognitive development.

Genie’s Early Experiences and Language Progress

Genie’s early life was shrouded in neglect and abuse, confined to a dark, isolated room by her parents for over a decade. Discovered at the age of 13, she exhibited severe developmental delays and lacked basic language skills. Through intensive intervention and specialized care, Genie made remarkable progress in learning language, albeit with significant challenges. Her journey from silence to rudimentary communication underscored the adaptive nature of the human brain and its capacity for linguistic development even after prolonged deprivation.

The Role of Language in Socialization

Genie’s case study illuminates the pivotal role of language in the primary socialization process. Language serves as a vehicle for communication, social interaction, and cognitive growth, shaping individuals’ perceptions of the world and their place within it. The absence of language during critical developmental periods, as seen in Genie’s isolation, can impede social integration, emotional expression, and cognitive functioning, highlighting the indispensable role of language in human development.

The Critical Period and Language Acquisition

Linguists posit the existence of a critical period for language acquisition, suggesting that optimal language learning occurs during early childhood when the brain exhibits heightened plasticity. Genie’s case study provides compelling evidence for this notion, as her delayed linguistic development and struggles with grammatical structures indicate the challenges of acquiring language beyond the critical period. While Genie’s progress demonstrates the brain’s capacity for adaptation, her linguistic deficits underscore the importance of early language exposure for optimal development.

The “Forbidden Experiment” and Ethical Considerations

Genie’s case study is often referred to as a “forbidden experiment” due to the ethical concerns surrounding her treatment and research protocol. The extreme social isolation imposed on Genie by her caregivers raises ethical dilemmas regarding informed consent, psychological harm, and privacy rights. The individuals involved in Genie’s case, including researchers and caregivers, faced criticism for potential ethical violations, such as inadequate protection of her well-being and exploitation for scientific purposes.

In conclusion, Genie’s story serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities of language acquisition, socialization, and ethical research practices. While her case offers valuable insights into the impact of extreme isolation on cognitive development and language acquisition, it also raises profound ethical questions about the boundaries of scientific inquiry and the responsibility to prioritize individual well-being. Genie’s resilience and progress stand as a testament to the human spirit’s capacity for adaptation and growth, even in the face of unimaginable challenges.


This question has been answered.

Get Answer