The Triumph of the Underdog: Overcoming Odds in Don Quixote and Pretty Woman

Analyze two texts (novels, films, television shows, song lyrics, and so on) Text Pairing Suggestion: Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra’s novel, Don Quixote: The Man of La Mancha and Gary Marshall’s film Pretty Woman and the idea of overcoming odds. write a paper presenting an idea found in the texts and exploring possible meanings. You will complete the project in two stages. Part 1: you will produce a 2 to 3-page draft as described above. This draft should be the very best work you can accomplish. You may use the tutoring lab and librarians for help. Part 2: you will be adding other voices to the discussion through the peer review: • You’ll be talking with others in class; and • In addition, you might wish to conduct some additional research to find out what scholars in the field have said about your discovered idea.
      The Triumph of the Underdog: Overcoming Odds in Don Quixote and Pretty Woman Introduction In both Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra's novel, Don Quixote: The Man of La Mancha, and Gary Marshall's film, Pretty Woman, the idea of overcoming odds is a prevalent theme. Both texts portray characters who defy societal expectations and triumph against all odds. This paper will explore how these texts present the concept of overcoming odds, examining the possible meanings behind this idea and its significance in the context of the narratives. Don Quixote: The Man of La Mancha Cervantes' masterpiece, Don Quixote, tells the story of Alonso Quijano, an aging nobleman who goes mad and believes himself to be a knight-errant named Don Quixote. Despite his eccentricities and delusions, Don Quixote sets out on a quest to revive chivalry and become a hero. Throughout his adventures, he faces numerous challenges and adversities, often leading to comical and disastrous situations. However, his unwavering determination and belief in his own ideals enable him to overcome these obstacles. The character of Don Quixote embodies the spirit of the underdog. He is an ordinary man who, despite his lack of physical strength and resources, takes on the world with courage and conviction. By challenging societal norms and pursuing his own vision of heroism, Don Quixote becomes a symbol of resilience and defiance against the odds. Pretty Woman In Marshall's film Pretty Woman, the protagonist Vivian Ward, a prostitute from a disadvantaged background, defies society's expectations and transforms her life. When she meets wealthy businessman Edward Lewis, their unlikely relationship becomes a catalyst for Vivian's personal growth. Through Edward's influence and support, she discovers her self-worth and develops the confidence to pursue her dreams. Vivian's journey represents the triumph of the underdog. Despite her marginalized position in society, she refuses to be defined by her circumstances. Through determination and resilience, she overcomes the challenges she faces as a result of her profession and background. In doing so, she finds love, happiness, and financial independence – a feat that seemed impossible given her starting point. Possible Meanings The idea of overcoming odds in these texts carries several possible meanings. Firstly, it highlights the power of personal agency and determination in shaping one's destiny. Both Don Quixote and Vivian refuse to be constrained by societal expectations and take control of their own narratives. Their actions demonstrate that even in the face of overwhelming odds, individuals have the ability to change their circumstances through sheer willpower. Secondly, these texts suggest that society often underestimates individuals who do not conform to conventional norms. Don Quixote's madness and Vivian's profession serve as labels that marginalize them within their respective societies. However, by defying these labels and transcending societal expectations, both characters prove that preconceived notions can be misleading. This challenges the audience to question their own biases and reassess their judgments about others. Furthermore, these texts emphasize the importance of empathy and compassion when confronting adversity. Don Quixote's unwavering belief in chivalry inspires those around him to see beyond his quirks and support him in his endeavors. Similarly, Vivian's vulnerability and genuine connection with Edward foster understanding and acceptance. In both cases, it is through empathy that barriers are broken down and bonds are formed. Conclusion The theme of overcoming odds in Don Quixote: The Man of La Mancha and Pretty Woman resonates with audiences because it speaks to the universal human experience of facing challenges. These texts remind us that even when faced with seemingly insurmountable obstacles, resilience, determination, and empathy can lead to triumph. By presenting characters who defy societal expectations and achieve personal growth, these narratives inspire us to believe in our own capacity for change. Ultimately, they serve as a testament to the indomitable human spirit and the transformative power of overcoming odds.  

Sample Answer