Utilitarianism and Integrity

Consider the scenarios involving the unwilling morals of agents of Jim and George in Bernard Williams “Utilitarianism and Integrity’. Describe the events that occur in each scenario (Detailed Descriptions) Explain how these events relate to the Brain in Vat scenario in Robert Nozicks “The experience machine.” Additionally explain how the thought experiments in each article exemplify objections regarding consequential judgement. Finally using the selection from Mill’s Utilitarianism to demonstrate how these objections might be unwarranted. Provide a detailed scenario that demonstrates your formulation of the unwarranted objections.



Sample Solution