VALUATION (Medfield Pharmaceutical session)
Consider the current sale of Oak Street Health to CVS as discussed in the attached article in Appendix B.
[a] How can you explain the purchase price by CVS of $10.6 billion (i.e., $39 per share–a 50% premium over the prior equity value of Oak Street) when they are still losing $200 million each year?
[b] How can each site of Oak Street do so well when their customers are almost all covered by Medicare and Medicaid and come from largely disadvantaged populations?
[c] How can you determine a total market value for a firm like this and what is the source of it? Would you buy more stock at the current price or sell what you have for $39 per share? Why?
Sample Solution
The purchase price of $10.6 billion (or $39 per share) that CVS paid for Oak Street Health appears to be largely driven by the potential future value they are foreseeing in this acquisition. Despite Oak Street Health still losing money ($200 million each year), there is strong evidence that their business model has been a success and will continue to be successful going forward given the right conditions.
Sample Solution
The purchase price of $10.6 billion (or $39 per share) that CVS paid for Oak Street Health appears to be largely driven by the potential future value they are foreseeing in this acquisition. Despite Oak Street Health still losing money ($200 million each year), there is strong evidence that their business model has been a success and will continue to be successful going forward given the right conditions.